Science Magazine Prize Goes to Computational Biology Course
“They do remarkable work for us,” said Susan McClatchy, outreach coordinator for the Center. “These students are really going places.”
The effective course module has been chosen to win the Science Prize for Inquiry-Based Instruction (IBI).
Science‘s IBI Prize was developed to showcase outstanding materials, usable in a wide range of schools and settings, for teaching introductory science courses at the college level. The materials must be designed to encourage students’ natural curiosity about how the world works, rather than to deliver facts and principles about what scientists have already discovered. Organized as one free-standing “module,” the materials should offer real understanding of the nature of science, as well as providing an experience in generating and evaluating scientific evidence. Each month, Science publishes an essay by a recipient of the award, which explains the winning project. The essay about QTM was published on 31 May.
“Improving science education is an important goal for all of us at Science,” said Editor-in-Chief Bruce Alberts. “We hope to help those innovators who have developed outstanding laboratory modules promoting student inquiry to reach a wider audience. Each winning module will be featured in an article in Science that is aimed at guiding science educators from around the world to these valuable free resources.”
The varied influences of McClatchy’s own background made her a natural for the QTM program—and for bringing the thrill of science to young people. Although she was always drawn to science and nature, it was in college that she found science and math instructors who “opened up an entirely new world” to her. Eschewing the big university experience as an undergraduate, McClatchy attended a community college and a state school, where classes were small. “That counted for a lot,” she said. “I was able to get to know these professors who were really passionate about science.”
After taking a job at the Jackson Laboratory in 2004, McClatchy taught extensively at research institutions and professional conferences. Her students were researchers interested in learning about the Jackson Laboratory’s Mouse Genome Informatics, a resource of data, tools and analyses involving mouse models that help with the study of human health and disease.
In 2010, McClatchy joined Gary Churchill, a statistical geneticist and director of the Center for Genome Dynamics, in providing a two-semester research course that included QTM to talented high-school students.
Students of the course, who attend public math and science magnet schools and come from a very wide range of financial backgrounds, meet with their teachers during the week and then attend a weekly Web conference with Churchill and McClatchy.
“The innovative use of Web conferencing removes traditional barriers to accessing intellectual resources: the scientists,” said Melissa McCartney, associate editor at Science.
McClatchy pointed out that all the students need in order to take the course is a computer and an Internet connection. “This is an opportunity for students from any kind of financial background to do cutting-edge research,” she said.
The students, like real researchers, begin with an extensive literature review on a chosen topic. They then formulate their own hypotheses, using data collected at the Jackson Laboratory or available from public collections, and choose analytical strategies to address their hypotheses.
Pursuing their own hypotheses, where there is no guaranteed outcome, is far more interesting and exciting than “cookbook” labs. The process, however, can be frustrating for students, particularly academically talented students who are used to knowing all the answers. “They’re used to an arrangement where, if you do the work, there’s this pot of gold at the end of the rainbow,” McClatchy said. “But real research isn’t like that. When they fail, it can be painful for them.”
Still, McClatchy says, “they always pull through. They persevere. It’s probably the most valuable lesson they get out of this.” The creators of QTM would like to expand its use, but the amount of time required of Churchill, McClatchy and the teachers is considerable. “We devote a lot of time to guidance and support,” said McClatchy. “Our time is not scalable, and the time of the teachers we work with is not scalable. It’s that labor and that devotion that’s limiting.”
QTM will be piloted this year as a program for undergraduate biology classes. McClatchy said professors at the college level are inclined to have more extensive scientific backgrounds, so they will most likely require less assistance. Also, they are more likely to have colleagues, such as computing specialists, with whom they can collaborate. Professors at the University of Maine and University of Connecticut are ready to use the curriculum this fall.
Read the essay, “Students as Collaborators in Systems Biology Research,” by Susan McClatchy and colleagues.
Learn more about the QTM module.
Read more about the Science Prize for Inquiry-Based Instruction.