Science: New Radiocarbon Record May Help Refine Ancient Age Estimates by Hundreds of Years
A new series of radiocarbon measurements from Japan’s Lake Suigetsu should help make radiocarbon dating more precise and accurate, especially for older objects, researchers report.
The work could be used to refine estimates of the ages of organic material by hundreds of years. Archaeologists, for example, may be able to further specify the timing of the extinction of Neandertals or the spread of modern humans into Europe. And climate scientists may better understand the chains of events that led to the advance and retreat of the ice sheets during the last glacial period.
“The new results offer an important refinement of the atmospheric radiocarbon record and place the radiocarbon timescale on a firmer foundation,” said Jesse Smith, senior editor at Science.
The research appears in the 19 October issue of the journal Science, which is published by AAAS, the nonprofit, international science society. The authors discussed their research with journalists in a 17 October Science/AAAS press teleconference and an 18 October press conference in Tokyo.
At the press conference—the first that Science/AAAS has hosted in Japan—about 40 journalists from major Japanese newspapers such as Yomiuri Shimbun and Asahi Shimbun and TV outlets such as NHK TV filled the room at the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology.
Reporters speak with the Science researchers at the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology in Tokyo. | Photo by Natasha D. Pinol
In Lake Suigetsu, a layer of tiny, relatively light-colored algae called diatoms blankets the floor each year, followed by a layer of darker sediments. The oxygen-poor lake bottom is very still, so these layers have remained undisturbed over tens of thousands of years. A series of cores drilled through these layers now provides an exquisitely preserved record of the past 52,800 years.
Researchers recognized as early as 1993 that sediment cores from Lake Suigetsu might be useful for radiocarbon dating, but the initial efforts encountered technical problems.
“In short, this is a realization of a 20-year-long Japanese dream,” said Takeshi Nakagawa of the University of Newcastle in the United Kingdom. Nakagawa is one of the primary authors of the study and leader of the Lake Suigetsu (SG06) project.
Radiocarbon, or C-14, is a naturally occurring, radioactive isotope of carbon that decays at a steady rate. Researchers can calculate the age of an object based on how much radiocarbon it contains relative to its stable cousin, C-12. But there are several factors that complicate this calculation, since the amounts of radiocarbon in the environment—and incorporated into growing organisms—can vary from year to year and between different parts of the global carbon cycle.
24,700 year-old leaf dated by radiocarbon. | Image courtesy of Richard Staff
Adjusting for these natural fluctuations in radiocarbon is a process called calibration and requires long, known-age records with associated radiocarbon data. Some of the longest and most important radiocarbon records come from marine sediments or cave formations. However, these need to be corrected using a variety of assumptions about how radiocarbon levels change in ocean water and groundwater.
The terrestrial sediment record now presented by Christopher Bronk Ramsey of the University of Oxford and colleagues requires no such correction. The radiocarbon in the leaf fossils preserved in the sediment comes directly from the atmosphere and is not subject to the same processes that affect radiocarbon in marine sediments or cave formations.
The only other direct record of atmospheric carbon comes from tree rings and extends to 12,593 years ago. The Lake Suigetsu record stretches back 52,800 years, extending the direct radiocarbon record by more than 40,000 years. Other, indirect radiocarbon records also reach back to roughly 50,000 years ago.
“In most cases the radiocarbon levels deduced from marine and other records have not been too far wrong. However, having a truly terrestrial record gives us better resolution and confidence in radiocarbon dating,” said Bronk Ramsey. “It also allows us to look at the differences between the atmosphere and oceans and study the implications for our understanding of the marine environment as part of the global carbon cycle.”
To construct their radiocarbon record from Lake Suigetsu, Bronk Ramsey and colleagues measured radiocarbon from terrestrial plant fragments spaced throughout the core. They also counted the light and dark layers throughout the glacial period to place the radiocarbon measurements in time. Many of the layers were too fine to be distinguished by the naked eye, so the researchers used a microscope, as well as a method called X-ray fluorescence that identifies chemical changes along the core.
A record of year-to-year changes, such as a sediment core, must be “anchored” in time by assigning some part of it an absolute age. The researchers did this by matching the first 12,200 years of their record with the tree-ring record, a well-established record that begins in the present.
A layer of light colored algae called diatoms, followed a layer of darker sediment, is laid down each year at the bottom of Lake Suigetsu. | Image courtesy of Gordon Schlolaut
Bronk Ramsey and colleagues also lined up segments of their record with those of other records from the same time periods and generally found good agreement.
“Because of the unique combination of a complete radiocarbon record and terrestrial paleoclimate data, Suigetsu can be a benchmark against which other records can be compared,” said Nakagawa.
“From a paleoclimate perspective, this radiocarbon dataset will also allow very high-precision, direct correlation between Suigetsu and other terrestrial climate records,” he added. “This allows us to see how changes in climate in different parts of the world relate to one another—and particularly where there are leads and lags. Information like this is very useful for studying climate mechanisms.”
“Although this record will not result in major revisions of dates, for example in archaeology, there will be changes in detail that are of the order of hundreds of years,” said Bronk Ramsey. “Such changes can be very significant when you are trying to look at human responses to climate, often dated by other methods, for example through the Greenland ice cores. So, a more accurate calibrated time-scale will allow us to answer questions in archaeology, which previously we have not had the resolution to address.”
Researchers generally use a composite record called IntCal to determine the ages of objects based on their radiocarbon measurements. The IntCal record incorporates data from multiple sources, including marine records, cave mineral deposits, and tree rings, and is updated periodically. Bronk Ramsey and colleagues anticipate that their Suigetsu data will be incorporated into the next iteration of the IntCal compilation, to be released in a few months.
Read the abstract, “A Complete Terrestrial Radiocarbon Record for 11.2 to 52.8 kyr B.P.,” by Christopher Bronk Ramsey and colleagues.
Listen to a 17 October Tokyo press teleconference with the Science authors.