Skip to main content

The Future of Voting Technology

How safe and secure are voting systems based on new technology?

The challenge of developing electronic voting systems is not only security but also protecting the secrecy of the ballot, a bedrock principle of free and fair elections. Currently there is “no known technology that can guarantee the secrecy, security, and verifiability of a marked ballot transmitted over the Internet.” 1

Online voting presents numerous vulnerabilities and is fundamentally insecure. There is potential for unobserved vote manipulation as well additional security vulnerabilities including potential denial of service attacks, malware intrusions, and privacy concerns.  Online voting does not produce a paper trail for auditing.

Blockchain-based voting, which relies on a decentralized, distributed digital ledger is vulnerable to many of the security flaws inherent in internet voting, such as the potential for malware to alter votes on a voter’s local device before the ballot is transmitted and the lack of secret ballots. Online and blockchain-based voting would greatly increase the risk of undetectable, nation-scale election failures.2

Multiple ongoing DARPA projects aim to develop secure hardware focused on developing hardware resistant to software- based attack through novel CPU designs. 3, 4 Future systems based on secure hardware could provide additional security, but the technology is still in early development.   

End-to-end verifiable election software relies on cryptography to encrypt and protect votes while allowing voters to see their vote was properly recorded, that the vote was correctly tabulated, and that the final vote count matches the cast votes. End-to-end verifiable software can be integrated into existing election systems to enhance the security of voting infrastructure.5 Recent open-source software packages including end-to-end verifiability systems, such as Microsoft’s software development kit ElectionGuard, could increase security if implemented in future elections.

 

Last updated March 10, 2021

References

1. National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine, Securing the Vote: Protecting American Democracy (The National Academies Press, 2018)

2. Park, S.; Specter, M.; Narula, N.; Rivest, R. L., Going from Bad to Worse: From Internet Voting to Blockchain Voting, 2021. Available online at: https://academic.oup.com/cybersecurity/article/7/1/tyaa025/6137886 

3. "Hacker Community to Take on DARPA Hardware Defenses at DEF CON 2019," DARPA, 2019. Available online at: https://www.darpa.mil/news-events/2019-08-01

4. "System Security Integrated Through Hardware and Firmware (SSITH) Proposers Day," DARPA, 2017. Available online at: https://www.darpa.mil/news-events/ssith-proposers-day

5. Appel, Andrew, "End-to-End Verifiable Elections," Freedom to Tinker, 2018. Available online at: https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2018/11/05/end-to-end-verifiable-elections/

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues
AAAS News

Video: The Risks of Internet Voting in the Puerto Rico Electoral Code of 2020

Office of Communications | Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues
AAAS News

Summit Briefs Policy-makers on Drinking Water Safety

Office of Communications | Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues | COVID-19 Resources
AAAS News

Top State Officials Urged to Bar Security-Flawed Internet Voting Platforms

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues | COVID-19 Resources
AAAS News

Scientific Experts Call on Elected Officials to Avoid Any Internet Voting

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues
AAAS News

Bringing Scientific Evidence to Meet Local Policy Challenges, a Town Hall at the AAAS Annual Meeting

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues
Statements

Statement on Ensuring Election Security

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues
AAAS News

On Election Day 2019, millions of Americans will cast their votes on paperless, insecure voting machines

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues
AAAS News

Statement on certification of voting systems in North Carolina

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues
AAAS News

Few New Jersey Counties Plan to Replace Electronic Voting Machines by 2020

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues

Video: Science, Technology, and the Vote: Safeguarding the integrity of our elections

Center for Scientific Evidence in Public Issues

Video: Policing, Public Safety, and Equity: Evidence and Insight for Better Policymaking